CIVS poll result

Poll description

I listed these out from memory, so if I forgot your favorite, I'm sorry. I start with the introduction of curved plastic because I have no interest in seeing nostalgia overtake ergonomics. "DS" Refers to Dual Shock, not the Portable.

Result

1. XB1 Elite (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices)

2. 360 loses to XB1 Elite by 16–9

3. XB1 loses to XB1 Elite by 18–6, loses to 360 by 16–7

4. DS4 loses to XB1 Elite by 18–8, loses to XB1 by 16–10

5. Xbox S-Type loses to XB1 Elite by 20–5, loses to DS4 by 16–9

6. The Duke loses to XB1 Elite by 18–5, loses to Xbox S-Type by 16–8

7. Gamecube loses to XB1 Elite by 20–5, loses to The Duke by 13–10

8. Super NES loses to XB1 Elite by 21–4, loses to The Duke by 13–8

9. N64 loses to XB1 Elite by 21–4, loses to Super NES by 14–7

10. Wii (inc. nunchuck) loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to N64 by 11–10

11. Dreamcast loses to XB1 Elite by 19–4, loses to Wii (inc. nunchuck) by 9–7

12. Genesis 6 button loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to Dreamcast by 10–6

13. Genesis 3 button loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to Genesis 6 button by 10–4

14. Dualshock loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to Genesis 3 button by 10–7

15. DS3 loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to Genesis 3 button by 11–6

16. Saturn Discus loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to DS3 by 8–6

17. Saturn loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to Saturn Discus by 5–4

18. DS 2 loses to XB1 Elite by 21–2, loses to Saturn by 7–5

19. NEO GEO loses to XB1 Elite by 21–1, loses to DS 2 by 7–5

20. PSX loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to NEO GEO by 5–4

21. PS 3 Boomerang loses to XB1 Elite by 21–1, loses to PSX by 6–4

22. Wii U Skateboard loses to XB1 Elite by 21–1, loses to PS 3 Boomerang by 5–4

23. 3DO loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to Wii U Skateboard by 5–3

24. Applejack loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to 3DO by 4–2

25. Jaguar loses to XB1 Elite by 21–0, loses to Applejack by 4–3

For simplicity, some details of the poll result are not shown.

Result details

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	19	20	21	22	23	24	25
1. XB1 Elite	-	16	18	18	20	18	20	21	21	21	19	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21	21
2. 360	9	-	16	19	20	22	24	23	24	25	24	25	23	25	25	25	25	25	25	25	25	25	24	25	25
3. XB1	6	7	-	16	18	20	22	22	22	22	22	23	22	25	24	25	25	24	25	25	24	25	24	25	25
4. DS4	8	7	10	-	16	15	19	18	19	19	18	18	19	18	20	19	19	20	19	19	20	19	19	20	19
5. Xbox S-Type	5	5	7	9	-	16	22	21	21	23	20	21	22	22	22	22	23	22	23	23	23	23	23	23	23
6. The Duke	5	3	5	7	8	-	13	13	13	14	13	16	16	16	17	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
7. Gamecube	5	1	3	3	3	10	-	10	13	11	11	12	13	17	16	14	14	17	16	16	17	16	16	16	17
8. Super NES	4	3	4	4	3	8	10	-	14	11	12	11	11	16	16	13	15	16	16	16	15	15	16	15	16
9. N64	4	1	3	5	3	7	7	7	-	11	12	11	12	13	15	14	14	14	15	15	15	16	15	15	15
10. Wii (inc. nunchuck)	2	0	3	4	2	7	7	8	10	-	9	9	9	13	13	11	11	14	13	13	14	15	13	13	14
11. Dreamcast	4	1	3	3	3	6	6	7	7	7	-	10	9	10	9	13	12	10	12	11	12	11	11	12	13
12. Genesis 6 button	2	1	3	4	2	6	6	7	10	8	6	-	10	12	12	12	12	13	14	13	13	12	13	13	14
13. Genesis 3 button	2	3	4	3	0	5	5	7	8	8	6	4	-	10	11	11	11	12	12	12	12	12	13	12	14
14. Dualshock	2	1	1	3	1	2	4	4	6	7	7	6	7	-	8	8	7	6	9	10	11	10	8	10	8
15. DS3	2	0	1	0	1	2	3	4	6	5	6	6	6	8	-	8	6	7	7	8	9	8	6	8	7
16. Saturn Discus	0	0	0	1	1	0	4	3	4	5	0	3	3	5	6	-	5	5	5	5	5	6	5	5	6
17. Saturn	0	0	0	1	0	1	3	2	5	4	0	2	2	7	6	4	-	7	6	6	6	6	5	5	7
18. DS 2	2	0	1	0	1	1	2	3	4	4	5	5	5	6	6	6	5	-	7	8	9	8	6	8	6
19. NEO GEO	1	1	1	1	0	2	2	1	4	3	1	0	1	4	7	5	3	5	-	5	6	4	5	5	6
20. PSX	0	0	0	2	0	2	2	1	4	3	2	2	2	4	6	4	3	4	4	-	6	5	4	5	5
21. PS 3 Boomerang	1	0	1	0	0	0	1	2	1	3	3	4	4	3	5	4	5	2	4	4	-	5	5	6	5
22. Wii U Skateboard	1	0	0	1	0	2	1	1	3	0	3	3	3	5	6	4	4	4	4	4	4	-	5	3	6
23. 3DO	0	0	1	1	0	1	1	1	3	2	1	1	0	5	7	4	3	5	2	4	4	3	-	4	4
24. Applejack	0	0	0	0	0	1	1	1	3	2	0	1	1	3	5	2	3	3	1	2	2	3	2	-	4
25. Jaguar	0	0	0	1	0	0	1	1	2	2	0	1	0	4	7	2	2	4	2	4	3	3	2	3	-

Ballot reporting was not enabled for this poll.

Rank 1:
XB1 Elite (24): vs. 22 : (9 - 16) vs. 19 : (8 - 18) vs. 23 : (6 - 18) vs. 20 : (5 - 18) vs. 13 : (4 - 19) vs. 6 : (5 - 20) vs. 21 : (5 - 20) vs. 4 : (4 - 21) vs. 5 : (4 - 21) vs. 7 : (2 - 21) vs. 9 : (2 - 21) vs. 10 : (2 - 21) vs. 15 : (2 - 21) vs. 16 : (2 - 21) vs. 18 : (2 - 21) vs. 0 : (1 - 21) vs. 8 : (1 - 21) vs. 17 : (1 - 21) vs. 1 : (0 - 21) vs. 2 : (0 - 21) vs. 3 : (0 - 21) vs. 11 : (0 - 21) vs. 12 : (0 - 21) vs. 14 : (0 - 21)
Rank 2:
360 (22): vs. 23 : (7 - 16) vs. 19 : (7 - 19) vs. 21 : (5 - 20) vs. 20 : (3 - 22) vs. 4 : (3 - 23) vs. 9 : (3 - 23) vs. 5 : (1 - 24) vs. 6 : (1 - 24) vs. 13 : (1 - 24) vs. 2 : (0 - 24) vs. 0 : (1 - 25) vs. 10 : (1 - 25) vs. 15 : (1 - 25) vs. 1 : (0 - 25) vs. 3 : (0 - 25) vs. 7 : (0 - 25) vs. 8 : (0 - 25) vs. 11 : (0 - 25) vs. 12 : (0 - 25) vs. 14 : (0 - 25) vs. 16 : (0 - 25) vs. 17 : (0 - 25) vs. 18 : (0 - 25)
Rank 3:
XB1 (23): vs. 19 : (10 - 16) vs. 21 : (7 - 18) vs. 20 : (5 - 20) vs. 4 : (4 - 22) vs. 9 : (4 - 22) vs. 5 : (3 - 22) vs. 6 : (3 - 22) vs. 7 : (3 - 22) vs. 13 : (3 - 22) vs. 10 : (3 - 23) vs. 2 : (1 - 24) vs. 16 : (1 - 24) vs. 17 : (1 - 24) vs. 18 : (1 - 24) vs. 0 : (1 - 25) vs. 15 : (1 - 25) vs. 1 : (0 - 25) vs. 3 : (0 - 25) vs. 8 : (0 - 25) vs. 11 : (0 - 25) vs. 12 : (0 - 25) vs. 14 : (0 - 25)
Rank 4:
DS4 (19): vs. 21 : (9 - 16) vs. 20 : (7 - 15) vs. 4 : (4 - 18) vs. 10 : (4 - 18) vs. 5 : (5 - 19) vs. 13 : (3 - 18) vs. 15 : (3 - 18) vs. 7 : (4 - 19) vs. 6 : (3 - 19) vs. 9 : (3 - 19) vs. 14 : (2 - 19) vs. 0 : (1 - 19) vs. 1 : (1 - 19) vs. 2 : (1 - 19) vs. 8 : (1 - 19) vs. 11 : (1 - 19) vs. 12 : (1 - 19) vs. 3 : (0 - 20) vs. 16 : (0 - 20) vs. 17 : (0 - 20) vs. 18 : (0 - 20)
Rank 5:
Xbox S-Type (21): vs. 20 : (8 - 16) vs. 13 : (3 - 20) vs. 4 : (3 - 21) vs. 5 : (3 - 21) vs. 10 : (2 - 21) vs. 6 : (3 - 22) vs. 12 : (1 - 22) vs. 15 : (1 - 22) vs. 16 : (1 - 22) vs. 18 : (1 - 22) vs. 7 : (2 - 23) vs. 9 : (0 - 22) vs. 0 : (0 - 23) vs. 1 : (0 - 23) vs. 2 : (0 - 23) vs. 3 : (0 - 23) vs. 8 : (0 - 23) vs. 11 : (0 - 23) vs. 14 : (0 - 23) vs. 17 : (0 - 23)
Rank 6:
The Duke (20): vs. 6 : (10 - 13) vs. 4 : (8 - 13) vs. 5 : (7 - 13) vs. 13 : (6 - 13) vs. 7 : (7 - 14) vs. 10 : (6 - 16) vs. 9 : (5 - 16) vs. 0 : (2 - 16) vs. 8 : (2 - 16) vs. 14 : (2 - 16) vs. 15 : (2 - 16) vs. 2 : (1 - 16) vs. 3 : (1 - 16) vs. 11 : (1 - 16) vs. 16 : (1 - 16) vs. 18 : (2 - 17) vs. 1 : (0 - 16) vs. 12 : (0 - 16) vs. 17 : (0 - 16)
Rank 7:
Gamecube (6): vs. 4 : (10 - 10) vs. 7 : (7 - 11) vs. 13 : (6 - 11) vs. 10 : (6 - 12) vs. 5 : (7 - 13) vs. 9 : (5 - 13) vs. 12 : (4 - 14) vs. 11 : (3 - 14) vs. 18 : (3 - 16) vs. 15 : (4 - 17) vs. 0 : (2 - 16) vs. 14 : (2 - 16) vs. 2 : (1 - 16) vs. 3 : (1 - 16) vs. 8 : (1 - 16) vs. 16 : (2 - 17) vs. 1 : (1 - 17) vs. 17 : (1 - 17)
Rank 8:
Super NES (4): vs. 7 : (8 - 11) vs. 9 : (7 - 11) vs. 10 : (7 - 11) vs. 13 : (7 - 12) vs. 5 : (7 - 14) vs. 12 : (3 - 13) vs. 15 : (4 - 16) vs. 18 : (4 - 16) vs. 11 : (2 - 15) vs. 17 : (2 - 15) vs. 16 : (3 - 16) vs. 3 : (1 - 15) vs. 8 : (1 - 15) vs. 0 : (1 - 16) vs. 1 : (1 - 16) vs. 2 : (1 - 16) vs. 14 : (1 - 16)
Rank 9:
N64 (5): vs. 7 : (10 - 11) vs. 10 : (10 - 11) vs. 9 : (8 - 12) vs. 13 : (7 - 12) vs. 15 : (6 - 13) vs. 11 : (5 - 14) vs. 18 : (6 - 15) vs. 12 : (4 - 14) vs. 16 : (4 - 14) vs. 0 : (4 - 15) vs. 14 : (4 - 15) vs. 2 : (3 - 15) vs. 3 : (3 - 15) vs. 1 : (2 - 15) vs. 8 : (3 - 16) vs. 17 : (1 - 15)
Rank 10:
Wii (inc. nunchuck) (7): vs. 9 : (8 - 9) vs. 10 : (8 - 9) vs. 13 : (7 - 9) vs. 12 : (5 - 11) vs. 15 : (7 - 13) vs. 11 : (4 - 11) vs. 18 : (5 - 13) vs. 0 : (3 - 13) vs. 14 : (3 - 13) vs. 16 : (4 - 14) vs. 2 : (2 - 13) vs. 3 : (2 - 13) vs. 17 : (3 - 14) vs. 1 : (2 - 14) vs. 8 : (0 - 15)
Rank 11:
Dreamcast (13): vs. 9 : (6 - 9) vs. 18 : (6 - 9) vs. 15 : (7 - 10) vs. 10 : (6 - 10) vs. 16 : (5 - 10) vs. 8 : (3 - 11) vs. 14 : (2 - 11) vs. 17 : (3 - 12) vs. 2 : (1 - 11) vs. 0 : (1 - 12) vs. 3 : (0 - 12) vs. 11 : (0 - 12) vs. 1 : (0 - 13) vs. 12 : (0 - 13)
Rank 12:
Genesis 6 button (10): vs. 9 : (4 - 10) vs. 15 : (6 - 12) vs. 18 : (6 - 12) vs. 16 : (5 - 13) vs. 8 : (3 - 12) vs. 12 : (3 - 12) vs. 17 : (4 - 13) vs. 11 : (2 - 12) vs. 14 : (2 - 13) vs. 2 : (1 - 13) vs. 3 : (1 - 13) vs. 1 : (1 - 14) vs. 0 : (0 - 14)
Rank 13:
Genesis 3 button (9): vs. 15 : (7 - 10) vs. 18 : (6 - 11) vs. 16 : (5 - 12) vs. 12 : (3 - 11) vs. 17 : (4 - 12) vs. 11 : (2 - 11) vs. 8 : (3 - 12) vs. 14 : (2 - 12) vs. 0 : (1 - 12) vs. 3 : (1 - 12) vs. 2 : (0 - 13) vs. 1 : (0 - 14)
Rank 14:
Dualshock (15): vs. 16 : (6 - 6) vs. 11 : (7 - 7) vs. 18 : (8 - 8) vs. 2 : (5 - 8) vs. 12 : (5 - 8) vs. 1 : (4 - 8) vs. 0 : (4 - 9) vs. 8 : (5 - 10) vs. 14 : (4 - 10) vs. 3 : (3 - 10) vs. 17 : (3 - 11)
Rank 15:
DS3 (18): vs. 2 : (7 - 6) vs. 11 : (6 - 6) vs. 0 : (7 - 7) vs. 1 : (7 - 7) vs. 15 : (8 - 8) vs. 16 : (6 - 7) vs. 8 : (6 - 8) vs. 12 : (6 - 8) vs. 14 : (6 - 8) vs. 3 : (5 - 8) vs. 17 : (5 - 9)
Rank 16:
Saturn Discus (12): vs. 16 : (6 - 5) vs. 0 : (5 - 5) vs. 2 : (4 - 5) vs. 11 : (4 - 5) vs. 14 : (4 - 5) vs. 17 : (4 - 5) vs. 8 : (4 - 6) vs. 3 : (2 - 5) vs. 1 : (2 - 6)
Rank 17:
Saturn (11): vs. 17 : (5 - 6) vs. 2 : (3 - 5) vs. 3 : (3 - 5) vs. 8 : (4 - 6) vs. 16 : (5 - 7) vs. 0 : (3 - 6) vs. 14 : (3 - 6) vs. 1 : (2 - 7)
Rank 18:
DS 2 (16): vs. 2 : (5 - 6) vs. 12 : (5 - 6) vs. 1 : (4 - 6) vs. 0 : (5 - 7) vs. 8 : (4 - 8) vs. 14 : (4 - 8) vs. 3 : (3 - 8) vs. 17 : (2 - 9)
Rank 19:
NEO GEO (0): vs. 8 : (4 - 4) vs. 12 : (5 - 5) vs. 18 : (7 - 7) vs. 14 : (4 - 5) vs. 17 : (4 - 6) vs. 2 : (2 - 5) vs. 3 : (1 - 5) vs. 1 : (2 - 6)
Rank 20:
PSX (14): vs. 2 : (4 - 4) vs. 1 : (4 - 5) vs. 8 : (4 - 5) vs. 17 : (4 - 6) vs. 3 : (2 - 5)
Rank 21:
PS 3 Boomerang (17): vs. 2 : (4 - 5) vs. 8 : (4 - 5) vs. 1 : (3 - 5) vs. 3 : (2 - 6)
Rank 22:
Wii U Skateboard (8): vs. 3 : (3 - 3) vs. 0 : (4 - 4) vs. 2 : (3 - 5) vs. 1 : (3 - 6)
Rank 23:
3DO (2): vs. 1 : (2 - 4) vs. 3 : (2 - 4)
Rank 24:
Applejack (3): vs. 1 : (3 - 4)
Rank 25:
Jaguar (1): vs. 3 : (4 - 3) vs. 14 : (5 - 4) vs. 18 : (7 - 7)

Feel like voting on something else? Try one of these public polls:

Condorcet Internet Voting Service

Poll Results: First Party Gamepads

Poll description

Result

Result details

Condorcet Internet Voting Service

Poll Results: First Party Gamepads

Poll description

Result

Result detailsHide details

Result details